• Home
  • Blogs
    • Politics & Policy
    • Just for Fun
  • Where I Stand
  • Letters
    • A Modest Proposal For Electoral Reform
    • Question Regarding May 22nd Article
    • Looking for a Critique of an Electoral Reform Idea I Had >
      • Prof. Andrew Heard's Reply
      • Prof. Tom Flanagan's Reply
  • SM-PV
  • Albert
  • Fundy Royal
The Tory Pirate

By-Elections Then & Now

4/9/2014

0 Comments

 
PictureSketch of one of the last open ballots 1872
I happened upon an interesting page on Wikipedia today showing every by-election in Canada since Confederation. Assuming the information is accurate it presents a fascinating snapshot of how Canadian political culture has changed over the years.

The Link

First off I'd like to admit that I was honestly surprised that the current Parliament hasn't gone much above average number of by-elections. It certainly feels like they are occurring more often. Although at 13 by-elections with a year to go in this Parliament it is slightly above average for the preceding ten Parliaments. The last Parliament to have more by-elections was the 30th (1974-1979) with 25!

41st Parliament (2011-present) Summary

By-elections so far: 13 (9 completed, 4 pending)
Parliament's Term: 3 years and counting
Causes: Resignations 12, Deaths 1

Just for fun lets compare with the 1st Parliament (1867-72) to see what differences there were.

1st Parliament (1867-72) Summary

By-elections: 46 
Parliament's Term: 5 years
Causes: Appointments 16, New riding 9, Deaths 9, To become a cabinet minister 6, Voided elections 1,
No election due to riots 1

The large number of appointments gives you an idea how much patronage was going on back then. I've included senate appointments in this total (although the technical terminology is 'being called to the Senate'). Regardless, of what you think of patronage appointments it is arguable that the ones made during this term kept Nova Scotia in the Dominion as one Anti-confederate was appointed to the Senate and Joseph Howe, a leader in the movement, joined the Conservative cabinet.

Nine by-elections also had to be held when Manitoba and British Columbia joined Confederation. Results were pretty evenly split between the Conservative and Liberal Parties with the addition of one independent rounding out the total.

Interestingly one of the nine deaths during the 1st Parliament was Thomas D'Arcy Etienne Hughes McGee, the only federal politician ever to be assassinated. He was killed by a radical Irish Fenian after leaving Parliament late one night. 

The six by-elections held because the MPs became cabinet ministers were due to an old rule that required you to run in an election if you were named to the cabinet. The theory being that voters should get to decide if they were ok with
their representative splitting time between the riding and their cabinet portfolio. In practice these by-elections were not usually contested. The practice was finally done away with in 1931 after a previous government was brought down because of them (part of the King-Byng Affair).

Conservative Barthélemy Pouliot's election was annulled and he stood in the subsequent by-election and won.

And finally there was one riding that did not hold an election in 1867 due to riots. As to what the riot was about I am not immediately able to find any information.

Hope you liked this look back at by-election history. In a short while I will post about Canada's unlucky 7th Parliament and its 83 by-elections.

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    James Wilson

    Likes: Government Transparency, Constitutional Monarchy, Politics

    Dislikes: Political Dishonesty, Canadian Republicans, Intellectual Property

    Ambivalent Towards: Pears, the Green Party 

    Archives

    November 2017
    June 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    2015 Election
    Alberta
    Albert County
    Assassination
    Brexit
    Britain
    By Elections
    By-elections
    Campaign
    Canadian Monarchy
    Climate Change
    Conservatives
    Convention
    Copyright
    Debate
    Democracy
    DPR
    Economy
    Education
    Elections
    Elections Canada
    Facebook
    First Nations
    Free Speech
    Fundy Royal
    GhostVolunteer
    Greens
    House Of Commons
    Independents
    Intellectual Monopoly
    Japan
    Just Not Ready
    Language
    Liberals
    Libertarian
    Link Storm
    Media
    Medieval History
    Mincome
    Minor Parties
    Monarchy
    NDP
    New Brunswick
    PANB
    Pirate Party
    Policy
    Poverty
    Prime Minister
    Progressives
    Provinces
    Quebec
    Quotes
    Random Thoughts
    R.B. Bennett
    Referendum
    Reform
    Republic
    Scotland
    Senate
    SM-PV
    Speaker
    Srsly Wrong
    Supreme Court
    Symbolism
    Technology
    The Tory Return
    Thought Experiment
    Unanswered Questions
    War
    Xkcd
    Yellowhead

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.