• Home
  • Blogs
    • Politics & Policy
    • Just for Fun
  • Where I Stand
  • Letters
    • A Modest Proposal For Electoral Reform
    • Question Regarding May 22nd Article
    • Looking for a Critique of an Electoral Reform Idea I Had >
      • Prof. Andrew Heard's Reply
      • Prof. Tom Flanagan's Reply
  • SM-PV
  • Albert
  • Fundy Royal
The Tory Pirate

Random Thoughts: Directly-Elected Executives Vs. Legislatures? 

10/10/2015

0 Comments

 
PictureThe US Senate in all its impotent glory.
While commenting on one of Warren Kinsella's older articles
(comment has not appeared as of this writing due either to
connection failure or queuing) I pointed out that when a
country has a directly-elected executive the executive tends to
win in any disputes it has with the legislature. Thinking on this
I realize that while there is a fair amount of anecdotal evidence
to support this position I haven't seen a published study on the
matter. Sure, directly-elected presidents have been shown to
​lower voter turn out for legislative elections and be less
willing to consult
 the electorate than either indirectly-elected
presidents or constitutional monarchs but do they cause
other harmful effects? Is an executive that has an advantage in
any fight with its legislature a bad thing?

And there is an advantage. The US President tends to be vastly more popular than Congress which gives them an
advantage in public disputes. My question is whether this imbalance in public goodwill is cause for concern. Well, cause
for concern for other countries. While our politicians actually have comparable levels of public goodwill to their US
counterparts (ie little) they don't have a directly-elected head of state to put the squeeze to them. They instead have an
executive appointed by the Crown made up of their peers which if it misbehaves ​badly enough can be tossed out. The
Prorogation Crisis illustrates this point. Harper had to work (lie) quite a bit to get the public on his side and he still had to
remove the contentious proposals from the budget bill to get it passed. I wonder if legislatures that have to deal with
directly-elected presidents can do as well. 

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    James Wilson

    Likes: Government Transparency, Constitutional Monarchy, Politics

    Dislikes: Political Dishonesty, Canadian Republicans, Intellectual Property

    Ambivalent Towards: Pears, the Green Party 

    Archives

    November 2017
    June 2016
    May 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    2015 Election
    Alberta
    Albert County
    Assassination
    Brexit
    Britain
    By Elections
    By-elections
    Campaign
    Canadian Monarchy
    Climate Change
    Conservatives
    Convention
    Copyright
    Debate
    Democracy
    DPR
    Economy
    Education
    Elections
    Elections Canada
    Facebook
    First Nations
    Free Speech
    Fundy Royal
    GhostVolunteer
    Greens
    House Of Commons
    Independents
    Intellectual Monopoly
    Japan
    Just Not Ready
    Language
    Liberals
    Libertarian
    Link Storm
    Media
    Medieval History
    Mincome
    Minor Parties
    Monarchy
    NDP
    New Brunswick
    PANB
    Pirate Party
    Policy
    Poverty
    Prime Minister
    Progressives
    Provinces
    Quebec
    Quotes
    Random Thoughts
    R.B. Bennett
    Referendum
    Reform
    Republic
    Scotland
    Senate
    SM-PV
    Speaker
    Srsly Wrong
    Supreme Court
    Symbolism
    Technology
    The Tory Return
    Thought Experiment
    Unanswered Questions
    War
    Xkcd
    Yellowhead

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.